When you buy a car: Inappropriate surgery

Here's an idea that should both empower consumers and nudge costs down.

When you buy a car, critical information for this major purchase decision is immediately available, and clearly and prominently displayed on key features of the product, e.g., the miles per gallon. The decision of whether to have surgery is just as important, but information as clear and objective as that is usually absent.

The National Priorities Partnership is a broad group of experts, convened by the National Quality Forum, who have agreed that certain operations are often unwarranted.

Patients who are considering a coronary artery bypass graft (CABG), hysterectomy, knee/hip replacement, prostatectomy, percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA), or spinal surgery should carefully consider beforehand whether the surgery is appropriate for them. To enable them to do so, patient advocates should find out and tell them the:

Survival rate;

Identification and frequency of the most common adverse effect;

Fraction of patients who need the operation to be performed again;

Best alternative to surgery; and

Cost to be billed by the surgeon and hospital.


I wish I had this information when I considered surgery. A friend's father also would probably have wanted to know it, as it might have saved him from an ineffective operation that left him incontinent. When consumers learn this information, many will probably consider alternatives to surgery, which may well be less expensive.