Planning hospital discharge with the patient: I wanted to watch him another day

Another story from Dr. Maren Batalden:
A few months ago, I treated an elderly gentleman with cancer who was getting chemo, so his immune system was compromised.  He got a urinary infection and ended up in the ICU [intensive care unit] with sepsis, needing specialized attention to support a very low blood pressure.  He got better surprisingly quickly with antibiotics and fluids.  He came to the regular medical unit late the following afternoon where I became the doctor in charge of his care.  I met him the next morning and he told me he felt fine and was ready to go home.  He’d been quite sick, so I wanted to watch him another day, especially because we didn’t yet have the culture results from the bacteria which caused his infection and we didn’t know which antibiotic would be safe for discharge.

I explained my concerns to him. “When will you have the culture results that describe my bacteria?” he asked.  I said tomorrow.  So he asked, “How about if you give me a dose in the hospital of an IV antibiotic that works for 24 hours, give me a prescription that is your best guess about an antibiotic pill that you THINK will treat my infection, let me go home, and call me tomorrow if we need to change the antibiotics. If we need to change it, we’ll change it then.”  I thought it was a great idea!  He said, “Why should I sit in the hospital waiting for lab results?!  If I feel terrible, I’ll come back.”  He did great!  I called him the next morning; the culture results confirmed that his bacteria was sensitive to the antibiotics I had prescribed. He felt well and continued his recovery without complication at home.

It used to be that when it was time to discharge someone, I figured it was largely my decision to make.  Many patients assume the same.  “You’re the expert, doc.  You tell me.”  But I have come to realize that it’s NOT my decision; it’s a shared decision. I understand what the labs and the physical exam are telling me.  But I don’t know really know how the patient feels compared to his or her usual state; I don’t really know what kinds of supports they have or don’t have at home.  Decisions about whether and when to admit a patient to the hospital and whether or when to discharge have to made together. To my surprise this framework has pretty significantly changed my practice.  I find myself keeping people in the hospital for another day or two, when left to my own devices, I might have discharged them earlier, or vice versa.  The best care, I have come to believe, is always “co-produced.”  

Thanks to Dr. Maren Batalden for her story. Read her article in the British Medical Journal on co-production of medical care.