Mother was convinced psychiatric meds were poison: Adverse drug reaction of diabetes

"Shyla" was a shy patient who ate nothing but white foods, and assaulted anyone who entered her airspace on the hospital ward. She was mute, but not uncommunicative. Some of her problem was her psychosis. Most of it was her mother, who was appointed by a court to be Shyla’s legal guardian and to monitor her medications. But her mother was convinced that psychiatric medications were poison. So Shyla would go home on weekend passes and return with all her pill bottles untouched, and without a shred of sanity.

This continued for months. Her mother brought a notebook to each visit that listed the side effects. Shyla’s doctors thought her mother was sadistic; she thought the doctors were evil experimentalists.

The doctors successfully persuaded a judge to remove the mother as a guardian and appoint someone else.

The guardian ensured Shyla took her meds. At first, Shyla flourished; she smiled, spoke, became lucid, joined a day program, began overnights in a residential house and was discharged. She seemed happy.

Then she got diabetes and required insulin. By then, studies had consistently found a link among her condition, antipsychotic medications, and diabetes. In 20/20 hindsight, it was clear that she had had an adverse drug reaction to the antipsychotic drugs . Her mother had been right.

As her doctor, Elissa Ely, concluded, "We doctors were innocent but at fault. The ground beneath professional feet should grow firmer over time – one ought to feel more certain of what one knows. But the more I know, the more I am afraid."

Advice: Have a healthy fear of possible side-effects, and use only the least amount of drugs to be effective.

Read Dr. Elissa Ely’s article in the July 24 NY Times.